|
|
此文章由 猫儿不笨 原创或转贴，不代表本站立场和观点，版权归 oursteps.com.au 和作者 猫儿不笨 所有！转贴必须注明作者、出处和本声明，并保持内容完整
本帖最后由 猫儿不笨 于 2015-11-23 18:29 编辑
greanbean 发表于 2015-11-11 17:34 
陪审团断案，大概是个什么程序？
是不是只要陪审团全体达成一致，然后有自己的论据，就可以做结论了。法官 ...
http://media.watoday.com.au/news ... idence-7002717.html 录像
Robert Xie trial : the key evidence
Louise Hall – Court Reporter 11/11/2015
The case against Robert Xie is circumstantial. There is no definite piece of evidence linking him to the crime scene. There are no eyewitnesses, and no survivors. Rather, the Crown says there are a series of facts, circumstances and evidence which, when you add them together, combine to prove beyond reasonable doubt that Robert Xie is the murderer.
Robert Xie maintains his innocence. In fact, the defence team are so confident that the circumstantial evidence isn’t enough to convict him that they chose not to present their own case.
Here are 5 key areas of evidence in the case.
DNA Evidence
Police found what appeared to be a smear of blood on Robert Xie’s garage floor. The Crown said it’s a mix of DNA from three of the victims. The defence, however, said forensic experts couldn’t prove the smear was blood at all.
Alibi
Robert Xie’s wife Kathy Lin said her husband had been at home in bed with her on the night of the murders, and had never left the house. This gives Mr Xie an alibi. The Crown has accused her of lying to protect her husband.
Motive
The Crown said Robert Xie had three motives for murder. Greed, pride and sex. A young woman claimed Xie groomed her prior to the murders, and once the Lin family was dead, he was able to sexually assault her. The defence argued the allegation were unsubstantiated, and should never have been submitted as evidence.
Video Evidence
Secret cameras allegedly caught footage of Mr Xie disposing of an Asics shoebox. This was after investigators questioned his wife about the type of running shoes he wore. The defence said that even if he was disposing of the shoebox, it was done out of fear that he was being set up.
Witness A
A career criminal referred to as Witness A befriended Xie in jail. He gave evidence that Xie admitted to sedating his wife on the night in question. He also said the pair devised plans to frame somebody else for the murders. The defence said that ‘Witness A’ was hoping his statement would lead to a reduction in his own sentence for drug supply.
终于有了比较清楚的正式报道----关于血迹DNA------的的确确就像我一直怀疑的，车库地面污迹里的DND只与3位男受害者有联系，而与2 女受害者没关系--------根本就不是媒介报道的与4个受害者有关 ！！！
唯一的结论是，车库地面发现的污迹，确实来自谢的妻子。正像另一法官John Andrews 怀疑的一样。这污迹跟林家凶杀案无关。
现在也可以说了，2012 年底开始，这DNA样品跑了几个国家，根本没发现什么新大陆。 |
评分
-
查看全部评分
|
2013 美西 冬游记 (2014-1-15) JerryWu 
参加活动——怀念丑丑 (2010-3-2) deepdeepsea 
发表于 2015-11-11 16:38
发表于 2015-11-11 17:06
